In my last article and video, I got ChatGPT to make me a DJ-friendly edit of This Charming Man by The Smiths, with beats at the start and end so it’s easy to mix in and out of. If you missed it, it’s here: How To Make Your Own DJ Edits With ChatGPT.
Most people were appalled, then fascinated, then off to have a go. Some pointed out, quite rightly, that you can get better results in a DAW.
What a lot of people missed were the musical decisions the AI made to get it sounding right. So in the video above, I make the same edit myself, the old-fashioned way, in DJ.Studio, to show you what those decisions were.
Getting the start right
DJ.Studio put the bars in for me, and it did a good job, even on music like this. What it couldn’t do was remove the bit of silence left at the start of the recording, so I had to trim that off first.
Then I had to listen carefully. The guitar doesn’t start on the first beat: there’s half a beat before it comes in, and that’s correct.
I only knew that because I know the track so well. Without that, I’d have gone wrong before I’d even started.
Finding beats to borrow
I needed eight bars of drums from somewhere in the track to put at the start and the end, so I chose the start of the first verse.
Morrissey sings “punctured” before the eight-bar section begins, because vocalists often come in early. There’s also one drum hit under that word, before the pattern starts properly, and I decided to take that too. It turned out to matter at the end.
I copied those eight bars as a drum stem, moved the original track along to leave eight bars of space, and dropped the drums in at the start. That gave me my intro.
Fixing the abrupt ending
The track stops dead. When I pasted the same drums onto the end, I could mix out, but there was a gap of a second or two before they kicked in, and it sounded disjointed.
The fix was that extra drum hit from the verse. I put it back, one beat before the drums start, and it tied everything together, as if the band had just carried on playing.
That’s the same decision the AI made in the first video.
What I needed to know as a DJ
Ironically, DJ.Studio is full of AI too: the stem separation and the beatgrid both are. But to do this well, I still needed to:
- know the track inside out, right down to where the guitar starts
- pick the right section to borrow the beats from
- hear that the ending sounded disjointed, and know how to fix it
That’s the point. If you don’t understand song structure, and how things come in and out around eight-bar phrases (but not always bang on the phrase), no amount of AI prompting will help you, because you won’t know what to ask for.
Learn this stuff first, and then whatever tools you use, from the loop button on your controller to the sync button to AI, you’ll know whether the results sound good.
Make your own edits, mashups and bootlegs
Our Laidback Luke’s Bootlegs, Mashups & Re-Edits course teaches you how to make unique versions of your favourite tracks to play in your DJ sets, from the ground up, with a DJ who’s had worldwide hits doing exactly that.
Find out more about Laidback Luke’s Bootlegs, Mashups & Re-Edits here.